The Gender Trap

There's a debate of sorts raging due to a certain former player arguing that women shouldn't be commentating, reporting or presenting on men's football. The main question I would ask, is: what makes a good presenter, pundit and commentator in sport?

These are some of the main elements I tell those that I coach;

1. Authenticity. Be true to yourself and who you are.

2. Warmth. Don't be too precious. Talk in a way people can relate to.

3. Be prepared. Do the research required and use your contacts to give insight.

4. Avoid cliches. Figure out way to say the stuff everyone has said over 100 times.

5. Inform and entertain. It's sport, not the news.

There are many more elements too. But the idea that gender comes into it, is a ridiculous, antiquated and pathetic stance.

Is Emma Hayes, less qualified for a role as a pundit than Alan Pardew?

Let's get personal. I spend much of my year commentating on women's golf. Yes, I commentate on men's golf too. And men’s football. But should I just stay in my lane with the men?

You could extend the gender arguement by suggesting only ex-pros should commentate on sport. But some of the great commentators never came anywhere near playing pro sport. Peter Drury and John Murray among my current favourites. Wouldn't want them up front for Fuham, though!

There are great players and excellent broadcasters. Very rare you get both. There are male and female broadcasters in sports tv who are very lucky to be given a high profile role, given their abilities and application. But invariably, they won't last. And I still have faith that the best will flourish.